Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 vs Babycakes CC-12 Cupcake Maker
The Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 and the Babycakes CC-12 are two of the more popular electric cupcake makers you can buy right now, and they share more surface-level similarities than differences. Both plug into a standard 120-volt outlet, both use a plastic or metal shell with a non-stick baking cavity, and both land in a similar price range under $80. Where they part ways is in wattage, material construction, and the size of their existing owner communities. The Holstein draws 1,440 watts and is built with a stainless steel housing, while the Babycakes CC-12 runs at 1,200 watts in a pink plastic shell that has attracted over 1,400 ratings averaging 4.7 stars.
Quick winner
The Babycakes CC-12 edges ahead for most buyers because of its higher average rating (4.7 vs 4.5) across a strong review base, slightly lower price at $69.99, and a footprint that keeps counter clutter manageable at 7.6 lb.
Key differences, measured
- The Babycakes CC-12 is 9% cheaper ($69.99 vs $77.12).
- The Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 is 240 W higher (1440 W vs 1200 W).
- The Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 is 642.4 lb heavier (650.0 lb vs 7.6 lb).
- Amazon buyers rate the Babycakes CC-12 0.2 stars higher across 4,900 combined reviews.
Side-by-side specs
| Spec | Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 Cupcake Maker | Babycakes CC-12 Cupcake Maker |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $77.12 | $69.99 |
| Rating | ||
| Wattage | 1440 W | 1200 W |
| Material | Stainless Steel | Plastic |
| Color | Black | Pink |
| Dimensions | 5.2 X 13.28 X 13.2 In | 13 X 13.5 X 5.5 In |
| Weight | 650.0 lb | 7.6 lb |
| Voltage | 120 Volts | 120 Volts |
The two contenders
Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 Cupcake Maker
The Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 is a 1,440-watt cupcake maker priced at $77.12, finished in black stainless steel that gives it a more kitchen-neutral look than the typical pastel options in this category. It has earned a 4.5-star average from 3,500 buyers, which is a meaningful sample size and suggests consistently solid results. The 5.2 x 13.28 x 13.2-inch body is compact enough for a standard counter. The higher wattage means it reaches baking temperature quickly, which matters when you are doing multiple batches.
Buy this if: Choose the Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 if you want a stainless steel finish that blends with a modern black or chrome kitchen rather than a brightly colored appliance. It also makes sense if you plan to run several batches in a row and want the slightly higher 1,440-watt output for faster heat recovery between batches.
Check price on AmazonBabycakes CC-12 Cupcake Maker
The Babycakes CC-12 is a 1,200-watt cupcake maker priced at $69.99, coming in pink plastic with dimensions of 13 x 13.5 x 5.5 inches and a weight of 7.6 lb. It runs on 120 volts and its rating of 4.7 stars across 1,400 reviews places it among the better-received appliances in this niche. At $7 less than the Holstein, it undercuts on price while actually outperforming it on average rating. The lighter wattage is unlikely to be noticeable in everyday baking of standard cupcake batches.
Buy this if: Choose the Babycakes CC-12 if you want the option with the higher buyer rating, a lower price, and a well-documented track record across a large number of owners. It is also the pick for gifting to bakers who prefer a fun pink aesthetic, and the 7.6-lb weight makes it easy to store when not in use.
Check price on AmazonFrequently asked questions
Which cupcake maker has better ratings, the Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 or the Babycakes CC-12?
The Babycakes CC-12 scores higher at 4.7 stars from 1,400 reviews compared to the Holstein at 4.5 stars from 3,500 reviews. Both are well-regarded, but the Babycakes has a narrower gap between its average and a perfect score.
Is there a wattage difference between these two cupcake makers?
Yes. The Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 draws 1,440 watts and the Babycakes CC-12 draws 1,200 watts. In practice, both heat up quickly and the 240-watt difference is unlikely to affect finished cupcake quality for home bakers.
Which one is cheaper, the Holstein or the Babycakes CC-12?
The Babycakes CC-12 is priced at $69.99 versus $77.12 for the Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002, making it about $7 less expensive at current listings.
Do both cupcake makers work on standard US household current?
Yes, both the Holstein Housewares OVS-17569790-002 and the Babycakes CC-12 are rated for 120 volts, so they plug directly into any standard US outlet without an adapter or converter.