Lehman's CU15358-SCS Waffle Iron Review
Our verdict
The Lehman's CU15358-SCS is a no-electricity cast iron waffle iron designed for stovetop or open-fire cooking, making it a niche pick for camping, off-grid living, or anyone who prefers old-fashioned cookware. At 3.9 stars from 516 reviews it gets decent marks, though the learning curve for cast iron waffle-making keeps it from universal appeal.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Campers, off-grid households, wood stove owners, and cast iron enthusiasts who want to make waffles without an electric appliance
Skip if
You want a plug-in electric appliance with consistent results and easy temperature control
- Material Cast Iron
- Dimensions 13.25 X 8 X 1.38 In
- Priced 43% above the category median ($34.99 across 96 tracked models)
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating3.9/5
3.9 average across 516 owner ratings
-
Popularity2.2/5
516 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other toaster ovens, convection and pizza ovens, toasters, stand and hand mixers, bread machines and baking appliances we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
This is a traditional stovetop waffle iron made from cast iron, measuring 13.25 x 8 x 1.38 inches. There is no electric heating element, no cord, and no thermostat. Heat comes entirely from the burner or fire beneath it, which means heat management is entirely up to the cook. Cast iron retains heat well once it is up to temperature, but reaching and maintaining the right heat on a modern gas or electric range requires attention.
At $49.98 it is priced competitively for a cast iron stovetop waffle iron. The flat profile and dimensions make it reasonable to pack for camping trips. Cast iron is durable and will outlast any electric waffle iron if properly seasoned and cared for. No voltage is required, so this works anywhere from a kitchen stove to an outdoor fire pit.
The 3.9-star rating from 516 reviews reflects a product that satisfies buyers who understand what cast iron stovetop cooking entails, but frustrates those expecting the simplicity of an electric iron. Results depend heavily on proper seasoning and heat management, which are not mentioned in any instruction insert according to some buyers.
Pros
- No electricity required, works on any heat source including campfires and wood stoves
- Cast iron construction is extremely durable with proper care
- Compact flat profile at 1.38 inches thick makes it easy to store or pack
- Works as a lifetime tool if seasoned and maintained correctly
- Priced reasonably for a cast iron stovetop waffle iron
Cons
- 3.9-star rating is below average for this category, reflecting a steep learning curve
- No thermostat or indicator means heat management relies entirely on the cook
- Requires seasoning and specific care that electric waffle irons do not
- Not suitable as a replacement for a standard plug-in electric waffle maker
Specifications
| Material | Cast Iron |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 13.25 X 8 X 1.38 In |
Performance notes
No wattage or voltage applies because this is a non-electric stovetop tool. Cast iron material retains and distributes heat well once the iron is fully preheated, but preheat time on a burner is longer than an electric iron. Dimensions of 13.25 x 8 x 1.38 inches suggest a standard single-waffle plate size. Weight is not listed in available data.
What buyers say
516 reviews with a 3.9-star average signals a product that works well for its intended audience but disappoints buyers who expected something closer to an electric appliance. Positive reviews tend to come from experienced cast iron users, while lower ratings often cite inconsistent heat and difficulty releasing waffles without adequate seasoning.
Similar toaster ovens, convection and pizza ovens, toasters, stand and hand mixers, bread machines and baking appliances to consider
Frequently asked questions
Can the Lehman's CU15358-SCS be used on an electric or gas range?
Yes, it can be used on any stovetop burner, including gas, electric, or induction if the base is compatible. It also works over an open flame or on a wood stove. The key is managing heat manually since there is no thermostat built in.
Does this waffle iron need to be seasoned before use?
Cast iron cookware generally benefits from seasoning before first use to build a natural nonstick layer and prevent rust. Coat the plates lightly with oil and heat them before the first waffle batch. Ongoing care after each use, including drying thoroughly and applying a thin oil coat, keeps the iron performing well over time.